April 9, 2015

Memo – Don’t Let Congress Kill a Deal: Oppose the Corker-Menendez Bill

View as PDF

Senators Bob Corker (R-TN), and Robert Menendez (D-NJ) have introduced S.615 – the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act, which claims to provide Congressional oversight of an Iran nuclear agreement but in reality threatens to kill any deal.

  • Congressional Veto: The bill enables Congress to veto any final deal.
  • Delay: The bill would directly interfere with the implementation of a final deal by delaying it for 60 days while Congress decides whether to veto it.
  • Non-nuclear Demands: This bill would require terrorism issues be resolved in a nuclear deal, inserting non-nuclear demands that could kill the talks.

S.615 Undermines U.S. Negotiating Leverage: The U.S. and its partners secured a strong framework agreement and are working to finalize the deal, but Corker-Menendez undermines our negotiators at the worst possible moment.

  • By delaying and revoking the President’s waiver authorities, this bill creates uncertainty that the U.S. can suspend sanctions, let alone ever lift them.
  • The U.S. is working to keep Russia, China, France, Britain, Germany and Iran on board to finalize the nuclear deal – adding 535 new negotiators to the talks is a mistake that risks isolating the U.S. instead of Iran.

S.615 Moves the Goalposts on Our Diplomats: This bill plays into the claims of Iranian hardliners who say the U.S. cannot be trusted to lift sanctions under a deal but will instead shift pressure to other issues.

  • The bill requires the President to certify that Iran has not supported terrorism against the U.S., which is beyond the scope of the already complex nuclear deal.
  • By adding new terrorism demands, Congress is shifting the terms of a deal and risks re-imposing nuclear sanctions even if Iran upholds the deal. 

S.615 Empowers Hardliners: This bill provides ammunition for Iranian hardliners and new tools to those in Congress who are committed to killing any agreement.

  • Adding terrorism demands and threatening to not uphold sanctions relief commitments empowers Iranian hardliners to argue against a deal.
  • Those in Congress behind outrageous stunts like the Netanyahu speech and Tom Cotton letter should not be given new powers to kill a deal.
  • Congress can have an oversight role and will ultimately decide whether or not to finalize the deal by lifting sanctions. But this legislation goes far beyond appropriate oversight.
Back to top